• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Our Authors
  • Contact Us

The Punjab Pulse

Centre for Socio-Cultural Studies

  • Areas of Study
    • Social & Cultural Studies
    • Religious Studies
    • Governance & Politics
    • National Perspectives
    • International Perspectives
    • Communism
  • Activities
    • Conferences & Seminars
    • Discussions
  • News
  • Resources
    • Books & Publications
    • Book Reviews
  • Icons of Punjab
  • Videos
  • Academics
  • Agriculture
You are here: Home / Areas of Study / Governance & Politics / Book Review: 1947 Kashmir Invasion, Why Stalemate?

Book Review: 1947 Kashmir Invasion, Why Stalemate?

August 14, 2020 By Guest Author

Share

Ajay Bhardwaj

Intrigues,conspiracies and fickle minds shaped the post-partition turmoil in J&K

Kashmir has been an inextricable thorn in the Indo-Pak relations which have remained strained ever since the partition.A series of incidents marked with intrigues and conspiracies overwhelmingly cast an ominous spell on the period and underscored conspiratorial designs at work.

The role of the Indian leaders, particularly that of Pt Jawahar Lal Nehru and Sheikh Abdullah,reflected their myopic vision and their crass inability to handle the crisis dexterously in the interest of the nation. So,  even after more than 70 years there seems to be no end to the conflict. Thousands of lives have been lost on either side of the Indo-Pak border, yet there is no hope of peace.

In his succinctly written book, 1947 Kashmir Invasion, Why Stalemate? Who Failed India,  former Punjab DGP PC Dogra, IPS(Retd), had delved deep into the factors that allowed the situation to boil on the border putting India permanently on a back foot.

Dogra, who has , so far ,authored three books and was instrumental in setting up of the Forum For Integrated National Security in 2003, has squarely underlined  Lord Mountbettan, Jawahar Lal Nehru and Sheikh Abdullah as the three characters  who scripted the ever-contentious history of the region to make the future generations suffer indefinitely.

Running into 260-odd pages the book quotes extensively from a number of references to substantiate the argument.

At the outset the author builds his premise that Pakistan had plotted soon after the partition  to coerce Maharaja Hari Singh to cede the Jammu and Kashmir state by signing Instrument of Accession in its favour and soon after the Partition the Pakistan Army aided by the Pakistan Prime Minister raised units of Lashkars which comprised tribesmen, equipped them arms and ammunition. The Pakistan Army had code-named it as Operation Gulmarg for which the D-day was fixed on October 22, 1947.

It was officially stated that the Lashkars were operating against Kashmir from bases in Pakistan with their modern military equipment like mortar, artillery and Mark v mines which could only be sourced from the Pakistan Army.

Quoting various accounts the book goes on to testify that there was a distinct

British design for building up Pakistan with Kashmir as a part of it.For this Lord Mounbettan made special efforts to warm up with the Pakistan authorities. Quoting Christopher Thomas, the book builds an argument about how it was a strategically carried out exercise by the British to properly up the Pakistani invaders and put the region on the boil. Thomas is quoted as saying

“It is entirely possible that the British incited the revolt by the tribals to ensure that the strategically vital region of Gilgit and Baltistan came under Pakistan’s jurisdiction in the expectation that Pakistan would cooperate in the Western defence pacts to block Russian ambitions”.

That the British wanted the region to go to Pakistan as India could not have allowed it to be used for spying or mounting attack on the then USSR happens to be a key eye-opener for the reader..

Could this be the reason that Lord Mounbatten kept Pt Nehru on tenterhooks and endorsed the Pakistan aggression covertly ?

After all, there  were large scale raids all along the border starting from Kathua to Bhimber by tribesmen totally supported by the regulars from the Pakistan Army, armed with modern weapons and commanded by the officers of the Pakistan army.

Image of Indo-Pakistan war, 1947-48

The chapter “Mountbatten as Governor General of India looked after the interests of Pakistan unconstitutionally” makes an interesting reading if only to underscore how Mounbatten did not want any Indian military operations against Pakistani raiders. Instead,”he wanted India to enter into negotiations with Pakistan…..No reinforcements were given to Srinagar, obviously as per the plan to blunt the Indian offensive. The Indian army was in a helpless state.”

The role of Maharaja Hari Singh compounded the matters no less.. He had three choices. First, to  accept accession to India, or  accession to Pakistan or stay independent. That he remained confused till driven to the wall only helped others to build on intrigues and conspiracies.

Josef Korbel, the then acting chairman of the UN Commission on Kashmir, said “Hari Singh favoured independence. Mounbatten told Hari Singh in June that Kashmir could not remain independent because neither India nor Pakistan could permit it. The Viceroy visited Hari Singh to make up his mind either way.

When Lord Mounbatten visisted Kashmir in June 1947, he advised the Maharaja to accede to Pakistan in consideration of its Muslim majority. If not he would have to agree to joining India..

So, Kashmir problem as it obtained today is a legacy of indecisive and weak leadership during the times. How Mounbattan plotted the call for plebiscite and how Nehru fell in line with it is another serious aspect that has been discussed in much detail.

Mountbatten writes to Maharaja Hari Singh…” my government has decided to accept the accession of the Kashmir state with the premise that it is my government’s wish that as soon as the law and order have been restored in Kashmir and her soil cleared of invaders, the question of the state’s accession should be settled by a reference to the people”. No such condition was added to the instruments of accession of other states. But the will of Mounbettan had to preail and Pt Nehru just gave in.

 

After Maharaja had acceded, what was the need for plebiscite?  Mr Jinnah had openly proclaimed that legally speaking the question of accession depended entirely on the choice of the ruler and the people of the state had no right to question his choice”.

Mounbatten, on the other hand, had been advising the Mahraja not to accede to any of the two dominions without ascertaining the wishes of his subjects by referendum,plebiscite, election oy representative public meetings”.

Pt Nehru, on the other hand, was in no mood to accept the accession unless and until his friend Sheikh Abdullah was firmly put in the saddle in J&K. “Nehru did not want a Muslim-majority state to accede to a non-Muslim majority country if the accession was not backed by the main political party of the state and its leader.

The book recalls a narration by Dr Karan Singh, ” National Conference met in September 1949 in Srinagar. Prime minister Nehru was also present. During the celebration the Indian national flag was conspicuous by its absence…the state flag had disappeared…it was the National Conference flag which was adopted as the state flag. Sheikh Abdullah kept arguing for an independent Kashmir guaranteed by the United Nations”.

“On 21 November Nehru made a statement in Parliament and reiterated his promise that the people of Kashmir would be given a chance to decide their future under the supervision of an impartial tribunal such as the United Nations Organisation”.

Just when Indian offensive was making headway, Pt Nehru started talking of a settlement with Pakistan and that left a big chunk of the Indian territory with Pakistan. It is from this region that Pakistan handed over the Aksai Chin sector to China and made this region a long-standing irritant for India to settle.

The chapters like “Was Nehru under emotional influence of Lord Mountbatten and Lady Edwina?”, “Mounbatten pressurised Nehru for reference to UNO”, “Pt Nehru himself was anti-Mahraja” delve in detail how Nehru failed to measure up the gravity of the situation and thus left a permanent thorn in India’s flesh.

(The writer is a Chandigarh-based senior journalist)

Book Details:

1947 Kashmir Invasion, Why Stalemate (Who failed India)

PC Dogra IPS, Ex-DGP, Punjab

Manas Publications


Share
test

Filed Under: Governance & Politics, Stories & Articles, Uncategorized

Primary Sidebar

News

ਪੰਜਾਬ ਚ ਖੇਡਾਂ

February 4, 2023 By News Bureau

ਸਿੱਖ ਫੌਜੀਆਂ ਲਈ ਹੈਲਮੇਟ ਲਾਜ਼ਮੀ ਕਰਨ ਦੇ ਫ਼ੈਸਲੇ ਦਾ ਵਿਰੋਧ

February 4, 2023 By News Bureau

ਪ੍ਰਨੀਤ ਕੌਰ ਕਾਂਗਰਸ ’ਚੋਂ ਮੁਅੱਤਲ

February 4, 2023 By News Bureau

आप सरकार के सत्ता में आने से पंजाब में आया बड़ा बदलाव

February 4, 2023 By News Bureau

मोटा अनाज खाएं; जल-जमीन और जीवन बचाएं

February 4, 2023 By News Bureau

Areas of Study

  • Governance & Politics
  • International Perspectives
  • National Perspectives
  • Social & Cultural Studies
  • Religious Studies

Featured Article

The actual message and etymology of Sri Guru Granth Sahib needs to be preserved

January 31, 2023 By Guest Author

Dr. Rajinder Pal Singh Sri Guru Granth Sahib, the eternal living Guru continues to inspire mankind and provide guidance for God realisation and truthful living. It contains the teachings of the Sikh Gurus as well as of Hindu and Muslim saints. Eternal wisdom flows from its teachings which are recited and sung with intense devotion […]

Academics

‘सिंघसूरमा लेखमाला’ धर्मरक्षक वीरव्रति खालसा पंथ – भाग-10 – भाग-11

सिंघसूरमा लेखमाला धर्मरक्षक वीरव्रति खालसा पंथ – भाग-10 विजयी सैन्य शक्ति के प्रतीक ‘पांच प्यारे’ और पांच ‘ककार’ नरेंद्र सहगल श्रीगुरु गोविंदसिंह द्वारा स्थापित ‘खालसा पंथ’ किसी एक प्रांत, जाति या भाषा का दल अथवा पंथ नहीं था। यह तो संपूर्ण भारत एवं भारतीयता के सुरक्षा कवच के रूप में तैयार की गई खालसा फौज […]

‘सिंघसूरमा लेखमाला’ धर्मरक्षक वीरव्रति खालसा पंथ – भाग-8 – भाग-9

सिंघसूरमा लेखमाला धर्मरक्षक वीरव्रति खालसा पंथ – भाग-8 अमृत शक्ति-पुत्रों का वीरव्रति सैन्य संगठन नरेंद्र सहगल संपूर्ण भारत को ‘दारुल इस्लाम’ इस्लामिक मुल्क बनाने के उद्देश्य से मुगल शासकों द्वारा किए गए और किए जा रहे घोर अत्याचारों को देखकर दशम् गुरु श्रीगुरु गोविंदसिंह ने सोए हुए हिंदू समाज में क्षात्रधर्म का जाग्रण करके एक […]

‘सिंघसूरमा लेखमाला’ धर्मरक्षक वीरव्रति खालसा पंथ – भाग-6 – भाग-7

सिंघसूरमा लेखमाला धर्मरक्षक वीरव्रति खालसा पंथ – भाग-6 श्रीगुरु गोबिन्दसिंह का जीवनोद्देश्य धर्म की स्थापना, अधर्म का नाश नरेंद्र सहगल ‘हिन्द दी चादर’ अर्थात भारतवर्ष का सुरक्षा कवच सिख साम्प्रदाय के नवम् गुरु श्रीगुरु तेगबहादुर ने हिन्दुत्व अर्थात भारतीय जीवन पद्यति, सांस्कृतिक धरोहर एवं स्वधर्म की रक्षा के लिए अपना बलिदान देकर मुगलिया दहशतगर्दी को […]

Twitter Feed

The Punjab Pulse Follow

The Punjab Pulse is an independent, non-partisan think tank engaged in research and in-depth study of all aspects the impact the state of Punjab and Punjabis

ThePunjabPulse
Retweet on Twitter The Punjab Pulse Retweeted
gopalsa22721269 गोपाल सनातनी @gopalsa22721269 ·
4 Feb

निकले तो भारत जोड़ने थे लेकिन यात्रा में बुलाया उनको जो कभी भारत को तोड़ने की बात कर चुके हैं!!

Reply on Twitter 1621779051957587968 Retweet on Twitter 1621779051957587968 12 Like on Twitter 1621779051957587968 19 Twitter 1621779051957587968
Retweet on Twitter The Punjab Pulse Retweeted
gopalsa22721269 गोपाल सनातनी @gopalsa22721269 ·
4 Feb

यही सोच कोंग्रेस को पनपने नही दे रही है जिसने कोंग्रेस का भला किया उसके साथ ऐसा ही व्यवहार करते हैं ??

Reply on Twitter 1621756288521875456 Retweet on Twitter 1621756288521875456 14 Like on Twitter 1621756288521875456 17 Twitter 1621756288521875456
Retweet on Twitter The Punjab Pulse Retweeted
ourindiafirst19 India First @ourindiafirst19 ·
4 Feb

स्वदेशी से बढ़ रही आत्मनिर्भर भारत की धाक 💪

Reply on Twitter 1621762337660350464 Retweet on Twitter 1621762337660350464 14 Like on Twitter 1621762337660350464 44 Twitter 1621762337660350464
Load More

EMAIL NEWSLETTER

Signup to receive regular updates and to hear what's going on with us.

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Phone
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

TAGS

Academics Activities Agriculture Areas of Study Books & Publications Communism Conferences & Seminars Discussions Governance & Politics Icons of Punjab International Perspectives National Perspectives News Religious Studies Resources Social & Cultural Studies Stories & Articles Uncategorized Videos

Footer

About Us

The Punjab Pulse is an independent, non-partisan think tank engaged in research and in-depth study of all aspects the impact the state of Punjab and Punjabis at large. It strives to provide a platform for a wide ranging dialogue that promotes the interest of the state and its peoples.

Read more

Follow Us

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Phone
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2023 · The Punjab Pulse

Developed by Web Apps Interactive